The philosophy behind the name
In medical school, every student learns the first rule of diagnosis: when you hear hoofbeats, think horses, not zebras.
The saying comes from Dr. Theodore Woodward of the University of Maryland School of Medicine, who told his students in the late 1940s not to go looking for zebras on Greene Street, the road outside the hospital. In medical slang, a “zebra” became any rare or exotic diagnosis — the thing you are trained, politely and systematically, to look away from.
Common things are common. As a rule of probability, it’s sound. Most hoofbeats really are horses.
But a rule of probability is not the same as a philosophy of care. Statistics describe populations. A patient is not a population — a patient is one person, in whom a disease is either present or it isn’t, and for whom being “unlikely” is no comfort at all if it happens to be true.
The razor, and its limit
Medicine loves Occam’s razor — the principle, named for the 14th-century friar William of Ockham, that the simplest explanation is usually the right one. One diagnosis should explain everything. It’s elegant. It’s often true.
But Indiana physician Dr. John Bamber Hickam offered the counterweight, now called Hickam’s dictum: a patient can have as many diseases as he damn well pleases.** Real bodies don’t read philosophy. A common condition and a rare one can live in the same person at the same time — and the tidy explanation can be the very thing that hides the dangerous one.
Dr. A. McGehee Harvey of Johns Hopkins said it the way every clinician should carry it: “In making the diagnosis of the cause of illness in an individual case, calculations of probability have no meaning. The pertinent question is whether the disease is present or not. Whether it is rare or common does not change the odds in a single patient.”*
That is the philosophy in one paragraph: probability tells you where to start looking. It was never meant to tell you when to stop.
The tools haven’t changed
There’s a quieter problem underneath. The physical exam we use to look hasn’t fundamentally changed in over a century: the stethoscope dates to 1816, the ophthalmoscope to 1851, the blood-pressure cuff to 1881. Those tools are then applied in visits that grow shorter by the decade — a system optimized to recognize the common quickly.
Meanwhile, the diseases that most determine how long we live — heart disease, cancer, metabolic disease — stay silent for decades. By the time they are audible with 1800s tools, they have often been running for years. A philosophy of “wait for the likely” meets its limit there.
What chasing zebras means in practice
Chasing zebras doesn’t mean testing everyone for everything, or treating every symptom as a catastrophe in waiting. It means refusing to let probability make the decision before anyone has actually looked.
It means holding two thoughts at once: the common explanation is probably right — and the question “what else could this be?” deserves a genuine answer, not a reflex. It means using modern diagnostics with judgment: advanced lipid testing like ApoB and Lp(a), coronary calcium scoring read alongside its limits, whole-body MRI when the picture calls for it, and the daily data from wearables — resting heart rate, heart rate variability, sleep — read as trend lines rather than snapshots. And it means regarding the patient as a participant in the search, not a bystander to it: the person who notices the change, reports the signal, and asks the second question.
Most of what any good clinician finds, most days, is horses — and treats them gladly. The philosophy isn’t to distrust the odds. It’s to remember what the odds actually are: a starting point for a population, applied to a person.
Probability is where diagnosis starts. It was never meant to be where it stops.
— Dr. Pooja Singh
Educational content, not personalized medical advice.
Sources & credits
* Harvey AM, Bordley J II, Barondess JA. Differential Diagnosis. 3rd ed. Philadelphia: Lea & Febiger; 1979, p. 15.
** Hickam’s dictum, attributed to John Bamber Hickam, MD, Indiana University School of Medicine.
* The hoofbeats aphorism and its Greene Street origin: Sotos JG. Zebra Cards: An Aid to Obscure Diagnosis. Mt. Vernon, WA: Mt. Vernon Book Systems; 2006 — and “Zebra (medicine),” Wikipedia.
* Occam’s razor history: William of Ockham (c. 1285–1347); the principle’s famous phrasing is John Punch (1639); the term “razor” was coined by Sir William Hamilton (18
Reading this with your own health in mind? Start with a free Fit Call.